(no subject)
Jul. 31st, 2011 01:01 pmEarliest Minoan palaces were believed to be redistributive centers like later Mycenaean ones
this interpretation is now being question
Knossos the only known site in Crete through the 5th millennium BCE (so some 3 millennia)
its great antiquity gave it a privileged position, access to the ancestors, etc.
Hepzefa Tomb in Egypt has Minoanizing elements in the ceiling pattern, 1953-1908
Why did Crete get more complex societies at the time everything else was collapsing? Maybe because supply was cut off because of collapses elsewhere, so instead of oversupply and inflation, we have scarcity and monopolies, which allow more stratified societies to emerge.
The climate change around 2200 BCE may have also encouraged concentration on the few most viable areas, and drawn attention away from the more marginal areas.
Neopalatial
Knossos had a throne; other palatial sites did not
150 By LM IA, Phaistos seems to have diminished in importance: no administrative documents come from Late Minoan contexts there, and there is little evidence for occupation in LM IB.
151 To support Knossos as a superregional island center, prestige and display objects that can only have been produced at Knossos were disseminated across the island. It is important to keep in mind that these Knossian objects may have bene produced for ceremonial purposes, because they often take ceremonial form (such as...impractical animal-headed pouring vessels and funnels known as rhyta,) and depict ritual scenes (bull-leaping, men at peak sanctuaries, and elaborately dressed women
152 the huge size of Knossos (the palace is almost twice as big as Phaistos), its continuity (no LM IB destruction within the palace)
153 Special Palatial Tradition pottery, most often reproduced in books, but not for every day use
floral style continued plant style that preceded it, but LM IB introduced marine style
potters seem to be following wall paintings, not innovative themselves
154 Scientific analysis has revealed that in general, Minoan pottery shapes and motifs were imitated, but that the vases themselves did not travel abroad. Marine style vases found outside Crete, for example, were often locally produced, not imports.
Virtually all Neopalatial arts and crafts on Crete originated in the Protopalatial period and continue to evolve, a good indication that the change from Proto- to Neopalatial did not involve a major cultural break despite the rise to a new level of technical competence
155 Minoan Type A swords have a grip that is riveted to the blade; the design is therefore not suitable for slashing but rather is good for thrusting and stabbing. These swords were the best produced in the Aegean, and ancestral to those that developed later. Although some of these Type A swords were used on Crete, many were deposited in the shaft graves at Mycenae. It would be interesting to know more about how the mainland élites acquired them; suggestions include spoils of war taken from vanquished opponents, armaments for retainers, or acquisitions made by mainland visitors to Crete. Armorers were responsible for two kinds of shields, the "tower" and the "figure-eight", both made of bull's hide stretched over a supporting wood or wicker framework: these are represented in art, though no actual examples survive.
156 silver "Siege Rhyton" from Mycenae, were found on the mainland, but were probably produced by Cretan artists
157 scraps of painted plaster at the site of Tell el-Dab'a (the ancient Hyksos capital of Avaris) in the northeast delta of Egypt. Among the surviving pieces are human figures, naturalistic landscape elements, and scenes of bull-leaping. do not copy Minoan frescoes in exact detail, may imply simple influence from Crete (date disputed, 16th century)
158 Boxer Rhyton
pieces of the Sanctuary Rhyton from Zakros were found scattered throughout the west wing of the palace. may be deliberate destruction for ritual purposes, or vandalization in the upheavals at the end of the Neopalatial period. Large-scale relief work in stone is notably absent from the Aegean, except the Lion Gate Relief at Mycenae, whose sculptural technique and iconography follow Minoan practices
159 red & green marble from the southern Peloponnese; green, black, & white-speckled lapis lacedaimonius from Sparta, and obsidian from Yiali, an island off the south west coast of Anatolia. Blue lapis lazuli came from a single known source in Afghanistan and amethyst from Egypt, whereas black hematite, blood-red carnelian, and rock crystal may have derived from several different sources, including Mesopotamia
160 from the eastern Med: elephant and hippopotamus ivory, glass, and faience
161 breechcloth secured at the waist, codpiece in combat and bull-leaping, kilt over this, cloaks/mantles depending on the weather, pointed leather sandals laced up the ankles, and sometimes leggings
this interpretation is now being question
Knossos the only known site in Crete through the 5th millennium BCE (so some 3 millennia)
its great antiquity gave it a privileged position, access to the ancestors, etc.
Hepzefa Tomb in Egypt has Minoanizing elements in the ceiling pattern, 1953-1908
Why did Crete get more complex societies at the time everything else was collapsing? Maybe because supply was cut off because of collapses elsewhere, so instead of oversupply and inflation, we have scarcity and monopolies, which allow more stratified societies to emerge.
The climate change around 2200 BCE may have also encouraged concentration on the few most viable areas, and drawn attention away from the more marginal areas.
Neopalatial
Knossos had a throne; other palatial sites did not
150 By LM IA, Phaistos seems to have diminished in importance: no administrative documents come from Late Minoan contexts there, and there is little evidence for occupation in LM IB.
151 To support Knossos as a superregional island center, prestige and display objects that can only have been produced at Knossos were disseminated across the island. It is important to keep in mind that these Knossian objects may have bene produced for ceremonial purposes, because they often take ceremonial form (such as...impractical animal-headed pouring vessels and funnels known as rhyta,) and depict ritual scenes (bull-leaping, men at peak sanctuaries, and elaborately dressed women
152 the huge size of Knossos (the palace is almost twice as big as Phaistos), its continuity (no LM IB destruction within the palace)
153 Special Palatial Tradition pottery, most often reproduced in books, but not for every day use
floral style continued plant style that preceded it, but LM IB introduced marine style
potters seem to be following wall paintings, not innovative themselves
154 Scientific analysis has revealed that in general, Minoan pottery shapes and motifs were imitated, but that the vases themselves did not travel abroad. Marine style vases found outside Crete, for example, were often locally produced, not imports.
Virtually all Neopalatial arts and crafts on Crete originated in the Protopalatial period and continue to evolve, a good indication that the change from Proto- to Neopalatial did not involve a major cultural break despite the rise to a new level of technical competence
155 Minoan Type A swords have a grip that is riveted to the blade; the design is therefore not suitable for slashing but rather is good for thrusting and stabbing. These swords were the best produced in the Aegean, and ancestral to those that developed later. Although some of these Type A swords were used on Crete, many were deposited in the shaft graves at Mycenae. It would be interesting to know more about how the mainland élites acquired them; suggestions include spoils of war taken from vanquished opponents, armaments for retainers, or acquisitions made by mainland visitors to Crete. Armorers were responsible for two kinds of shields, the "tower" and the "figure-eight", both made of bull's hide stretched over a supporting wood or wicker framework: these are represented in art, though no actual examples survive.
156 silver "Siege Rhyton" from Mycenae, were found on the mainland, but were probably produced by Cretan artists
157 scraps of painted plaster at the site of Tell el-Dab'a (the ancient Hyksos capital of Avaris) in the northeast delta of Egypt. Among the surviving pieces are human figures, naturalistic landscape elements, and scenes of bull-leaping. do not copy Minoan frescoes in exact detail, may imply simple influence from Crete (date disputed, 16th century)
158 Boxer Rhyton
pieces of the Sanctuary Rhyton from Zakros were found scattered throughout the west wing of the palace. may be deliberate destruction for ritual purposes, or vandalization in the upheavals at the end of the Neopalatial period. Large-scale relief work in stone is notably absent from the Aegean, except the Lion Gate Relief at Mycenae, whose sculptural technique and iconography follow Minoan practices
159 red & green marble from the southern Peloponnese; green, black, & white-speckled lapis lacedaimonius from Sparta, and obsidian from Yiali, an island off the south west coast of Anatolia. Blue lapis lazuli came from a single known source in Afghanistan and amethyst from Egypt, whereas black hematite, blood-red carnelian, and rock crystal may have derived from several different sources, including Mesopotamia
160 from the eastern Med: elephant and hippopotamus ivory, glass, and faience
161 breechcloth secured at the waist, codpiece in combat and bull-leaping, kilt over this, cloaks/mantles depending on the weather, pointed leather sandals laced up the ankles, and sometimes leggings